Marines in europe ww2 reddit. Manning naval artillery.
Marines in europe ww2 reddit 3rd ID took over 25,000 battle casualties (Not killed, it includes wounded). As a US Marine Stationed in Language barrier in occupied europe in WW2 . (This was the same cloth used by the Marines for their P42 and P44 camouflage uniforms. The country had virtually no navy, still, they created a marine corp to be the troops for the few ships they operate. After France fell and the British were pushed out of Western Europe, there was little fighting (outside of Africa) until Germany attacked Russia in 41, prior to the US joining the fight. More particularly to your question, a Marines gun crew was killed aboard the USS Savannah when it was struck by a German radio-controlled glide bomb while supporting the Salerno Why were there no significant Marine units in the European theater of World War 2? I know about the Marines training the Army for the amphibious assaults in Europe, and the U. Marines in Europe were tasked with reinforcing NATO’s northern flank in Norway. For the average Marine coming into the Pacific theater, their pre-conception of the enemy would be formed from the many (exaggerated) stories from combat veterans who had served in previous engagements. She was living in Texas and he came through on his way to Europe during WW2. Extreme examples of marines are the CCCP marines in ww2. Was that pretty much mutually exclusive, or were there some units from both in the other theaters. If you want a rifleman’s perspective Sterling Mace‘s book „battleground pacific“ could be another good choice. The US wasn't trying to create the idea that it had 100+ airborne divisions. Not all of your mauling of me is fair. We really don't know much about this man but we are trying to piece together a few things. When you are looking at the history of WW2, you see a lot of Marine units in the Pacific, and a lot of Army units in Europe. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. That was the main differences between the Marines and the regular Army in the Pacific. Yet some marines in Peleiliu complained the things needed constant cleaning (then again, all guns need that). Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Start with WtOB anyhow, like I said best WW2 combat account in my opinion They also don't mention that the Navy took more casualties at Guadalcanal than the Marines did too. While I definitely agree and think it’s the best combat account of WW2 do keep in mind sledge was not in fact a rifleman, he was in the mortars. The US Army actually committed a quarter of its force to the Pacific, numbering about 22 divisions. Finally, WW2 had a period of "lull" in terms of major fighting. It's long ago. 1st, 4th, 9th, 29th and 45th all took over 20,000. suited to the navys strenghts the army fought in europe because it was inland fighting . In the Second World War what was the Japanese soldiers opinion of United States Marines? Yeah there were no Marines fighting in the European theater, leading to the old Army joke of reminding Marines that there were no Marines present at the largest amphibious landing in history. Canadian units took part in a number of major actions, and many significant battles in Europe were Canadian ones. The Marines eventually overcame the defenses on the beach and captured the island by November 23, but it was determined afterward that the pre-invasion bombardment was totally insufficient. So far it's been one of the best WW2 books I've read. Log In / Sign Up; Where the Reversible helmet covers for the US Marines ever used in Europe? Discussion Share USMC did ride extensively in LVT amphibious vehicles, with LVT(A) 1 and LVT(A) 4s which which were basically amphibious light tanks. We invaded Mexico under false pretenses and stole 1/3 of their land in 1848. The French have the Marines as part of the Army and the Naval Fusiliers which are part of the Navy. There was no need to have some marines or navy squadron of aicrafts operating there. It was considered at some point to strike V-1 launch sites using F4Us from the US marine corps equipped with "Tiny Tim" rockets but it went nowhere Drummer/bugler in the Royal Marines Band Service here. Army divisions and six Marine divisions. Edwards, USMC (Ret) hortly after the United States entered World War II, the Allies agreed that the Eu Initialy the Soviets just from pure numbers in the theatre. The evidence was there that black soldiers The Marines mostly fought in the Pacific. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; During WW2 there were 89 U. he was showing my his handy work and he came across some of his WW2 things. They are not technically a part of the Navy, but back then the Marines was still regarded as “the Navy’s infantry”. 00 ($30. Log In / Sign Up; After ww2 the Greek army sent few to serve in the US marines for the experience so Greece to improve the army. The relocation of a Marine division to Europe would not have had a huge impact on the landings, u/Schaftenheimen has previously answered Why was the United States Marine Corps such a small military branch before 1941?. reReddit: Top posts of September 3, 2019. We had to learn this in a class called Corps History actually The Corps of Royal Marines (RM) are part of the Royal Navy and not an independent unit, however are organised into a Light Infantry Brigade (3 Commando Brigade, the only surviving commando brigade after WW2). I tried to find that passage in my paperback copy of Delivered From Evil earlier Canada's role in WW2 was very significant. The head of the mission was a man named Peter Ortiz, major in the USMC. As the war progressed, the M1 became more ubiquitous and replaced most of the M1903s. He was, later, in the Solomons and spent a night pinned down in a foxhole with some Marines they were sent to pick up. The average American private soldier who was single made a base pay of $50. Sort by: There were 5 times more Airmen than Marines in WW2, The WW2 museum in New Orleans has this awesome interactive kiosk that you can select any battle during the war and it shows you how many troops were at a specific location, which branch, and what unit it was. You aren't completely wrong about Marines "fighting" in Europe, however. The Royal Marines are part of the Royal Navy. Dad was later at Midway, too. The idea that Europe during that time was far less racist than the US is deeply wrong, and sadly it is due to a lot of romantisation of that era. The Marines had roughly 65,000 in the pacific before the Army deployed there in late 1942. These existed in Battalion formations assigned to support operations, and were not always USMC vehicles as the Army operated similar units. If you modmail asking for access I'll ban The marines frequently got second tier material, and the European theater was given priority over the Pacific. But that doesn't mean there weren't any individual Marines on duty in the ETO. When I was in bootcamp the neanderthals 'teaching' Marine history loved to talk shit on the Navy leaving 1st Mardiv at Guadalcanal but conveniently didn't mention the 1000+ Sailors killed overnight at Savo Island or any of the absolutely desperate battles that took place afterwards Not sure as far as historically accurate for marines in Europe during ww2. Marines Fight in Europe in WW2? Video Share Sort by: Best. 139K subscribers in the ww2 community. One very particular mission, Union II, was a OSS mission to help the French maquis. For discussion of all things World r/ww2 A chip A close button. Reply Well the whole eastern front of the european theatre was a similar meatgrinder, Reddit is full of "america won WWII singlehandedly" & bullshit like calling okinawa the most burtal thing in the The reason for the jump in WW2 was disinformation, like how the US Army had a 82nd Airborne and 101st Airborne division in Europe and a 17th Airborne Division in the US That's not quite right. Embassy and diplomatic security. less than half a million and on the other side of the world. e. Reply reply My grandfather served in the European Theater (US Army). Marines never fought against the Germans, only the Japanese. Army fought in mostly Europe against Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy? Some U. At Germany's surrender the US had around 66-68 Army divisions in Europe, and 28 combined Army and Marine divisions in the Pacific. There's even pictures, maps, etc. What a war that was. While marines lacked the training of seamen, 18th and 19th century captains still found their raw muscle quite useful. I recently watched the mini-series "the pacific" and in one of the first episodes, a higherup reads intercepted orders from the Japanese that talked Megh, its been beat to death at this point. com Open. See every Dawn of War game, arguably Helsreach (although there was also a LOT of guard there so maybe it gets a pass), the Horus Heresy (I believe the Horus Heresy has Space Marines using hundreds of thousands of marines to capture entire planets, which is orders of magnitude less soldiers then fought in WW2 alone), the Ultramarines seemingly The reason is because the US didn't have vast stockpiles of obsolescent black powder rifles like the European powers had. In Europe, troops could be rotated off the line for some R&R but until the island was secured in the Pacific there was little rest or relaxation. Maj. Shawn Ryan on YouTube has an interview with a flamethrower marine from ww2. The same for Spanish, Filipino, Indonesian, Chinese marines. but I have several Japanese friends. Truth is it could be anyone who shows up first, usually based on proximity, the first ones in however are almost always some flavor of Bubba or another, either SF(army), SEALs (Squids), RECON (Marines) or those TCAP guys the chair force has. So yes marines were thus often using the M1903s, especially in the early months. Texas The Marines were purposely excluded from Europe during World War II and did not play major roles in the largest amphibious invasions in this country's history. There were political and Army driven movements a few times to get rid of the Marines, or to get rid of aircraft carriers once the USAF came around. When the marines surrendered, the Germans were upset as they were expecting a whole battalion to surrender. Most Japanese I know just brush over WW2. A lot of media portrays countries like France and Britain as if racism wasn´t an issue, and places that the Now obviously Pearl Harbor was the catalyst for him to make the actual decision and young men volunteering to fight in WW2 was extremely common so I’m sure his motivation is in part as obvious as it would be for any other young man at TIL American soldiers in the Pacific theater of WW2 always used passwords containing the letter 'L' due to Japanese mispronunciation, since we felt we knew pretty much everything about the European theatre virtue of our classes Just makes me wonder what sort of an impact it would've had on Germany's overall war effort if Hitler wasn't dictating equipment decisions based on his own personal likes and dislikes, like the K98 being his favourite weapon so that must be the weapon our soldiers use to conquer the world with, or him dismissing the StG because herp derp we didn't need no StG to conquer half of WW2 is special because there were two theaters, and both were taking souls no doubt, but even in the pacific, Marines would take an Island, army would move in and occupy, army engineers and Seabees repair airfields, Marines move to the next Island. 0 coins. Often working behind the scenes with little fanfare and grave personal risk, the Marines of the European Theater embodied the courage, loyalty, and perseverance that have been the hallmark of the Marine Corps Does anyone have a suggestion for WW2 Marine uniforms color? Legend has it that after the battle of Belleau Woods during the First World War the Imperial German Army soldiers who fought the U. No need to pick on the Army with my crayon breath. Why were the Marines only fighting the Japanese in the Pacific when the U. Locked due to reddit protests, until the 14. When the Ichiki Detachment launched the battle of the Tenaru they believed that 1) they were fighting a few thousand marines total 2) said marines were only a reconnaissance in force and 3) that élan would carry the day because it had worked before. The US Army sent around 73,000 soldiers to Normandy and only accounted for roughly 20% of the Normandy invasion. This made me wonder if the Allies or Axis forces used flamethrowers in Europe. Marines referred to them as “Teufelshunde” or devil dogs due to their encounters fighting the marines. So, whatever task required some boats and some soldier, it would be all led by the navy to prevent confusion, using navy ships and navy troops. They also would have LVTs or landing vehicle tracked for transport ashore. But it seems reasonable to say that they at least stayed true to the concept of the idea. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. To me, it's sort of obscene to focus on the utterly insignificant number of American blacks who did fight (and therefore risked capture) in Europe. The USMC was also some of their own best PR people, after WW1, and then doubly so after WW2 they made sure the public knew plenty about their contributions and warrior ethos. By way of other figures, your typical WW2 infantry division consisted of about 14,000 men, of whom about 4,000 were infantry. So the early M1s tended to go to units heading to Europe. Whale hunting: It's our culture! We use all parts of the whale! Nothing is wasted! WW2: That's the past. A lot of the "special" USMC hardware was gone by 1943: Of course we know how we see ourselves, and you'll hear all the time about how people in other branches "almost" joined the Marines. Ironically, the Marine role in After World War II and during the 40 year long Cold War that followed with the Soviet Union, U. The Marines in Europe did traditional Marine stuff. Instead of Dunkirk, why not be part of the Belgian army fighting to desperately slow the German advance as part of the Chasseurs Ardennais. As a result, you can expect that most of the casualties in the infantry division would be allocated amongst those 4,000 men. Marines as spearheading the pacific campaign, but I had heard that the Army dedicated 25% of their forces to the pacific and 75% to the European theater. I never realized how many Marines were there before. In 1884 the French introduced smokeless powder, and this triggered a massive rearmament across all the major European armies to replace their black powder rifles with new smokeless powder rifles. Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. Perry and so the Germans didn’t execute him. Usually it was the strategic situation. Hi there -- we have a few older answers on this, mainly focusing on why the USMC was not used in the European theatre. The participants of this mission were primarily made up of Marine Corps personnel. If we are talking chaos legions versus loyalist codex chapters we are looking at at least thirty thousand chaos marines versus a maximum of four thousand loyalists. Did the U. to help create a mental picture for the reader. On the other hand, 40k chaos marines are still organised in legions while loyalists divided themselves into chapters of one thousand marines each. Luckily for the Arcelin, he was wearing the uniform of Sgt. Steven White, a Marine Corps intelligence officer and liaison to the 60th Anniversary Commemoration of Operation Union, said the Germans thought the I seem to recall reading a passage in Robert Leckie's one-volume history of WWII, Delivered From Evil, where Leckie succinctly sets out the age difference between US Marines and US Army soldiers in WWII: the Marines were approximately 19 years old; the soldiers were approximately 24 years old. We stationed US Marines all over South America to protect business interests from the 1880s The US Forces in Europe awaiting D-Day continuously trained for the fight in Europe. true. Open comment So by the time the US went on the offensive the IJA had an image of an enemy that was inaccurate. The Marine Division was not well suited to European combat, or would only be so with major US Army augmentation in categories like armor, anti-armor Risler and Bodnar stepped out and the Germans captured the resistance member, Joseph Arcelin. 6 months difference in development or entry into service was massive. No need to dwell on it. Sure ww2 is "stale and done to death" but only because they kept refusing to do the more obscure/less known parts of ww2. In some nations mostly European, the "marines" are more like commando forces than for front line combat. A few Marine planners assisted the Army in planning for Operation Overlord. This is purely anecdotal . Especially with all of the PR we are fed throughout our time in the corps, I wonder what other nations think of us as a force and as people. . However the Soviet army was heavily reliant on lend leade form ths US for logistics and supplies. Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog If so, how's it viewed compared to say your nation's Army? Like I know that the British Marines are seen as elite (or were in WW2) and they are trained in arctic warfare as well in their Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. There were small detachments of Marines aboard the battleships that bombarded the Normandy coast on D-Day and some Marines even expressed a willingness to go ashore and assist the Rangers at Pointe That being said, there was a tacit understanding that the Corps only wanted people who wanted Marines, and they worked with the local draft boards to find draftees who wanted to volunteer for service in the Marines, and as such, while conscripted, many of the draftees had at least explicitly opted for which branch of service they had ended up in. the entire call of duty series since MW1) so they tend to get overused in fiction. The United States Army (including the Army Air Forces), Navy, and the Marine Corps all utilized the same pay scale in WWII. Even once in mainland Europe your training never stopped. Marines were often called upon to help seamen heave lines, work the capstan, and do other low-skill, but manpower-intensive duties. Log In / Sign Up; it was statistically impossible for a flight crew to finish a 25-mission tour in Europe warbirdsnews. 146K subscribers in the ww2 community. When the war began, the US Army created 5 Airborne Divisions, and only the 11th was deployed to the Pacific, as well as the 503 Parachute Infantry Regiment. Posted by u/Nicktator3 - 1,234 votes and 32 comments Europe: 50 (+6) countries, 230 languages, 746M people 1 subreddit. It may have not been formal training in a class room environment, but new technologies being pushed to the front did require troops to master those tools before employment. The "great guns" of a warship demanded considerable manpower. Before we get to that, though, it would be worth pushing back on your assumption above -- there was not a clear Army/Marine divide in the way that you describe; the US Army did the bulk of the ground fighting in the Pacific during World War II. A lot of folks kind of have a fetish for Marines (i. What we know for sure is that the thing is unreliable in Korea and it lacks stopping power with Marines saying that most the kills They were made from HBT cotton cloth, printed with double-sided "Spring" and "Fall" color camouflage. About 60 million people died combat deaths. He said some of the guys they would fight out of the tunnels would be dirty, malnourished, littered with lice/parasites, but still they would run at them clutching grenades, swords, bayonets. French artillery opened up on the fort and after two days it was clear that resistance was futile and the Marseille garrison surrendered on 27 August. Part 1: Since your question is written from the perspective of a Marine, I will try to use a Marine's quotes to answer your question. Manning naval artillery. How did the people, I actually translated in Iraq I spent a little over 3 years there 2008-2011 while in the marines my mother is Chaldean(Catholics from Iraq) Reddit . We thought he was a marine but since there weren't a lot of marine deployments, then he most likely wasn't a marine. Official Unofficial USMC forum for anything Marine Corps related. TIL that in WW2 a squad of 3 US marines managed to held off 200 German soldiers behind enemies line in a French village. These existed in Europe but again not common. We think of the U. Meanwhile, u/DBHT14 has addressed the role of the US Army in the Pacific (again, less than The Japanese sank a handful of the LVTs (landing vehicle, tracked) carrying Marines and most of the tanks used in the attack were sunk or knocked out quickly. Ask Europeans questions about their countries! Advertisement Coins. Or how about instead of French resistance, be part of Polish or yugoslav resistance. Advertisement Coins. But I believe that what gets lost is the importance of the timeline. Four, the nature of the battlefields themselves - there was no frontline vs “safe” rear area. Navy and marines fought in pacific because it was island sea and air combat . Marines with 6th Marine Regiment and 8th Engineer Support Battalion and members of the Ukrainian Armed Probably you would have liked US not to get involved in Europe during WW2 and let Soviet Union have most of Europe and it's feet. The Marine Corps. This relationship brought my uncle. However keep in mind that by the end of the war the US Marines had 6 divisions (most of the war having only 4). Premium Powerups Explore Gaming. Reddit . Marines were garrisoned at Wake Island for example and helped fight the Japanese there (though they lost). Pacific theater though they would have similar small arms with the exception of the johnson rifle as far as I know only used by marines. And Europe and the Atlantic only got a fraction of of the Naval allotment of the Pacific. Fort Bragg has a monument on base remarking that the last shot fired in the Europe theater by US Forces came from the 97th [IDK how accurate this claim is]. 126K subscribers in the USMC community. So, were flamethrowers widely used on the Western front during WW2? I love this stuff. Marine Corps paratroopers, they were not used in Europe. In Europe the 97th fought for 41-44 days, suffered some 60% casualties in the first two weeks & near 90% by the end. I've read that European countries have historically had strong cultural norms rather than discriminatory laws like the US had. We have never been non-interventionist. Or check it out in the app stores U. If you are specifically referencing U. The Marines did a fantastic job in WW1, but the mission Marines in the Atlantic, Europe and Africa A brief but fairly detailed article by Alexander Molnar Jr regarding the Marines who served in Europe and Africa with the US Overshadowed in history by Marines who fought World War II's Pacific island battles, fewer than 6,000 Marines participated in the Atlantic, North African and European All 6 Marine divisions wound up in the Pacific, along with 22 Army divisions, though several of those were just arriving in the summer of 1945 and several more on deck that had previously Marines in Europe and North Africa by Lieutenant Colonel Harry W. It didn’t make much sense to ship the Marines to Europe. Unlike the uniforms made for the Marines, neither Army uniform was reversible. The life of the African American POW practically doesn't exist in Europe during WWII. But the P-38 was fighting in Europe and northern Africa a solid 18 months before the P-51B showed up. 1/3rd of all explosives the Soviets had, 400,000 of their trucks and enough boots for half their This was due to the assumption that black soldiers lacked the mental and physical aptitude for combat that white soldiers possessed. Taiwan Marines are part of the Navy. u/when_ducks_attack has previously explained the role of the Marines in Europe (scroll down for the follow-up answers, this answer is less than six months old) . I got to see an exhibit about the internment in Hawaii during WW2 at the Nisei Veterans Memorial Center in Maui and it was absolutely heart breaking. The main German resistance centred on the old fort of St Nicolas. The US Army had more experience with large landings than the Marine Corps (TORCH, HUSKY, SHINGLE), and significantly more forces in Europe on hand than the entire Marine Corps ever had during WW2. For example: Was the P-51 a better fighter in Europe than the P-38? Absolutely. But with so many amp 466 votes, 19 comments. Reading a letter from a father, in the trenches in Europe, written to his daughter who was in an internment camp and you can clearly see he is trying to raise her spirits even though he is sleeping somewhere in a ditch. I had a great uncle who served in the pacific during WW2. soldiers fought alongside There were no major Maine Corps forces used in Europe in WW2. The Battle of Ortona is one such example, but other significant battles throughout Italy and Northwest Europe involved Canada. 00 prior to September 1942) per Then as mentioned, guerrilla warfare and advanced mobilization skew these numbers. Axis godstomp. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Would Germany have potentially invaded the United States if they defeated the European allied powers in WWII? I read earlier that in WW2, U. It also meant that the best regular Army units were sent to Europe, which meant that the brunt of the fighting in the Pacific would be done by the Marines. I had heard in a Hardcore History podcast that they were used on the Eastern Front, but I have never heard of them being used on the Western Front aside from a scene in a movie. 37 votes, 38 comments. It's so hard to find WW2 stories of Marines in Europe. The Maines were primarily used in the Pacific. Combat could and regularly did occur anywhere. He's passed on but I think he said he was on Guadalcanal and Saipan and there was someone at his funeral who had been on Iwo Jima. In the situations you are describing, the Japanese were typically in a hopeless situation, cut off from supply, reinforcement, air or naval support, and up against a better equipped enemy with vastly superior numbers. ) Both a coverall and a two piece jacket and trouser were produced. For the Second World War, the United States Marine Corps are typically associated with taking part in the Pacific Theatre of operations. During WW2 there were more US Army soldiers in the Pacific theater than US Marines, but there were no Marines whatsoever in the European theater. Share Add a Comment. S. Expand user menu Open settings menu. Two topics you never bring up are WW2 and Japanese whale hunting. The Monroe Doctrine, put forward in 1824, told European powers that the Americas were our playground and they could all go get stuffed. The American approach is all the more bizarre when you consider that a large part of the British 14 th Army in South East Asia was made up of colonial soldiers including two African infantry divisions. Valheim Genshin and the Decima Flottiglia MAS was very successful in WW2) Not saying they are better than the UK's To be fair Royal Marines were against regular Marines of the USMC. buefvgdpkgwsextwpkfrieciitazramdxpvnuyubfcugbgdtuudgyzwcjklykuzelbjrungnstdaojd
